The Hunt for Gollum Could Show Gandalf Interrogating Gollum

CBR explains how The Hunt for Gollum could depict Gandalf using fear to question Gollum, based on Tolkien’s account of events in Mirkwood.

CBR reports that The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum will be directed by Andy Serkis, who will also reprise Gollum, alongside Ian McKellen as Gandalf. Set largely during The Fellowship of the Ring, the film will also bring back Aragorn and Frodo. Serkis and McKellen last appeared together in a Lord of the Rings film in 2012’s The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey.

The story draws on the appendices of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Return of the King, which say that Aragorn captured Gollum in 3017 and took him to Mirkwood. In The Fellowship of the Ring novel, Gandalf tells Frodo that he questioned Gollum there and used the fear of fire to get the truth from him. The article describes this as psychological torture, while noting that Gandalf believed the interrogation was necessary to protect Frodo and the One Ring.

The film cannot directly adapt passages that appear only in The Fellowship of the Ring, but its use of the appendices leaves the filmmakers room to shape the Mirkwood interrogation. The article says the scene could omit torture or follow Tolkien’s account more closely. It also notes that Gollum had previously been imprisoned and physically tortured in Mordor, which may have made Gandalf’s threat of fire especially distressing.

  • Director: Andy Serkis
  • Gandalf: Ian McKellen
  • Gollum: Andy Serkis
  • Setting: Largely during The Fellowship of the Ring
  • Year of Gollum’s capture: 3017

Join 12AM

Get new posts by email, and choose the topics you want.

Get in Touch

Send a message about screenings or press.

Related