Andy Weir Wanted Two Project Hail Mary Scenes Cut

Andy Weir says he argued to cut Project Hail Mary’s astrophage spacewalk and Eva Stratt karaoke scenes, both of which the directors kept.

/Film reports that Andy Weir tried to remove two scenes from the film adaptation of his 2021 novel, Project Hail Mary. The author told the outlet that he thought the sequence of Ryan Gosling’s Ryland Grace surrounded by glowing astrophage did not advance the plot. He also objected to the scene where Sandra Hüller’s Eva Stratt sings karaoke, partly because he felt the character would not do so.

Directors Phil Lord and Chris Miller kept both scenes despite Weir’s objections. The astrophage moment shows Grace on a spacewalk as the Hail Mary passes through the Petrova Line; the sequence was largely filmed in camera using infrared lights and on-set devices, as shown in an IMAX Instagram video. The karaoke scene was added by the directors and gives a glimpse of Stratt’s turmoil over sending a man to die to save the world.

The film’s first cut ran four hours before Lord and Miller trimmed it to two hours and 36 minutes. Weir said viewers have embraced the scenes he wanted removed, and joked that he should not direct or be involved in editing. The article also recalls that he initially disliked the cover art for the 2015 film adaptation of his novel The Martian, which later won awards.

  • Author: Andy Weir
  • Directors: Phil Lord and Chris Miller
  • Runtime: 2 hours and 36 minutes
  • Based on: Andy Weir’s 2021 novel Project Hail Mary

Join 12AM

Get new posts by email, and choose the topics you want.

Get in Touch

Send a message about screenings or press.

Related