Sci-Fi Short Film: "The Right Choice" | DUST
Episode Description
A married couple visit a clinic to decide what attributes their designer baby should have.
The Right Choice by Vijay Varman & Tomisin Adepeju
About DUST: DUST presents thought-provoking science fiction content, exploring the future of humanity through the lens of science and technology. From timeless classics to cutting-edge movies, series, short films, and podcasts, DUST acquires, produces and distributes all content types.
Connect with DUST Website: http://www.watchdust.com Sign-up for DUST newsletter: http://eepurl.com/b_SKAz Watch DUST on your TV: Available on Roku, Samsung TV, Apple TV, Android TV...and more Watch more on YouTube: http://bit.ly/2amTSen Follow Us on Facebook: http://bit.ly/2aqYgtZ Follow Us on Instagram: http://bit.ly/2amAhRt
Listen to the DUST podcast: Apple: http://bit.ly/DUST-Audio Spotify: http://bit.ly/DUST-Spotify Stitcher: http://bit.ly/DUST-Stitcher Castbox: http://bit.ly/DUST-Castbox iHeart: http://bit.ly/DUST-iHeart
About Gunpowder + Sky: Creating content that resonates and impacts pop culture conversation, by empowering creators to take risks and experiment relentlessly in the pursuit of novel stories and formats.
https://www.youtube.com/watchdust Subscribe to the DUST and ALTER newsletter: http://eepurl.com/dChYXb
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [NURSERY RHYME PLAYS IN BACKGROUND] [WIFE] Wow. [HUSBAND] Look at that! Look at this up here.
- Oh! Lovely. Just so lovely. [LAUGHS] This is so exciting! I know! [ADVISER] Hello there!
- So sorry we had to meet in here. One of those human rights activists threw a brick through my office window last night.
- Glass everywhere. Now you are... Mr and Mrs Dimka? That's us. Welcome to the Arbitrio clinic.
- I will be your personal adviser, advising you through this incredible journey we're embarking on.
- We're very excited! [LAUGHTER] [ADVISER] As you should be. Here at the Arbitrio clinic we take great pride in designing babies
- that perfectly meet your needs. It's so nice when people are open to new methods of procreation.
- Not that there's anything wrong with the usual boy/girl way. After all, before I came out of the closet I was known to dabble in my fair share of penis!
- [LAUGHS] [FORCED LAUGHTER] So, shall we begin? Lets! Question number one. Boy or Girl? Both--
- Girl! Oh, sorry. [LAUGHTER] Someone's an eager little bunny! My wife and I have really been hoping for a girl.
- Of course. Who wouldn't want a bouncing baby girl? But we really want to give this child the best possible start in life, don't we?
- I... I don't understand. Oh, don't be alarmed. As your adviser I'm just making sure we explore every available option.
- Why wouldn't a girl be the right choice? Let's be honest. It's a man's world out there.
- Something like two women every week die of domestic violence. Not to mention all that sexual harassment from puberty onwards.
- Hell, sometimes it starts before puberty! In fact, now I think about it, if you take the both of us
- and the two women at reception on average at least one of us has been raped! [LAUGHS]
- Well... Um... Maybe-- No. Honey, you wanted a girl. I wanted a girl. We'd prefer a girl.
- Of course. Brilliant choice. Question number two. Heterosexual or Homosexual? What?
- Oh, I'm sorry. Straight or Gay? No. That's not... I know what that means. I meant; you can do that?
- But of course! Being gay is perfectly natural. Hundreds of creatures are known in the animal kingdom to be gay.
- And if it's natural, we can change it I don't think we're too concerned about her sexuality.
- We'd love her whatever. That's right. Of course, of course. Gay rights and all of that.
- We could make her bi-sexual and let her choose. But I have to ask you. Are you sure?
- I only ask because... Well, do you keep your marriage a secret? From your colleagues at work?
- No. Why would we need to do that? Well, a quarter of gay people keep their relationship secret from their colleagues.
- Because? Well, let's be honest. It's quite the hassle being openly gay, isn't it?
- All those "faggots" thrown at them at school. Never seeing themselves as the heroes.
- And ever since the EU collapsed... Only 20 countries in the world still bother to recognise gay marriage.
- Look... I say this as a person that's advised hundreds of parents. But perhaps it's best to side with caution on this one.
- After all, the right choice is the one that will keep your child safest. Fine, make her straight.
- You won’t regret it. And now for our final question. What skin colour would you like?
- These are the colours that we can offer. And before you ask... We can’t make your baby bright blue. That’s illegal!
- That one please. Of course. Now, again, as your adviser I just want to make sure
- we’re making the right choice for your baby. With this choice of skin colour, your baby
- can expect to be four to five times more likely to be stopped by the police than the average person.
- Of course, not when she’s a baby. I mean, that would be weird. I mean when she grows up.
- If your baby has a degree she will be two and a half times more likely to be unemployed
- and can also expect to earn 23% less than white people with the same degree. She’s three times more likely to be murdered.
- Seven times more likely to be detained under the mental health legislation. And three times more likely to be permanently excluded from school.
- So, not great news I’m afraid. What on earth can we do to fix that? Well, you can... Maybe have a baby...
- That starts with a “W”. We... We should have a witty baby? Starts with a “W” and has an “E” in there.
- A wise baby? A Whuu... A Whuu-- A Welsh baby? No... (Holy Mother of...) A baby that’s...
- Whhiitt... Whhiitt... Whhiiii-- A white baby?!? Great idea! You want us to "Michael Jackson" our baby?
- No, of course not! But... err... Everybody wants to give their child the best possible
- start in life, don’t they? Just think about what white skin gives you. Better chance of staying out of prison, higher wages,
- more acting jobs, less profiling. Almost every aspect of her life will be better.
- Are you completely insane? You want me to give birth to a white baby? Hey, well, that’s a little racist.
- A little? There’s no way we’re having a baby that will make everyone think she’s been sleeping with the milkman.
- Oh... Well, actually our milkman’s black. Whatever! Okay, okay. I’m just trying to help you make the right choice.
- How about you meet me half-way? An Asian baby? No, no, no. I mean many of my clients have chosen a shade that’s slightly lighter than
- they are themselves. For example... If you go a couple of shades lighter, That would reduce the average number of police stops by approximately half.
- But she wouldn’t look like us. On the contrary. There’s a difference between facial structure and skin tone.
- She would look like a mixture of you both, I can guarantee it. The only difference is that she might have a slighter lighter shade.
- We’ve done pretty well so far. Oh, there’s no argument there. So, she could do okay.
- But can you guarantee it? You can’t guarantee it either. Of course, of course. But when you can’t guarantee,
- Doesn’t everyone make a choice that’s as close as possible? Why choose a horse that’s a thousand to one, when you can
- choose one that’s two to one? What’s important to bear in mind here is this... If you make the right choice, your daughter can have a much better life.
- There are always problems. Life is full of them. But making the right choice today
- will mean that life will be just that little bit easier. She can grow up into a young woman and...
- Be happy. And in the end, isn’t that what we all want? It’s just so strange. I know it feels like that now,
- but of the 600 or so clients I’ve seen so far, over 350 have chosen a shade lighter than themselves.
- And nobody around them has been any the wiser. That many? I know all of my clients and I know none of them have regretted their choice.
- I can show you some testimonials if you like. Has anyone asked to be darker? Well, I’m not... Err...
- It’s possible that some of my colleagues have been asked. But not you? But let’s not worry about that.
- After all, we’re not Superman. We can’t turn the world backwards and make it better.
- So... What’s your choice? [SILENCE] Okay... Yeah. We’ll make her a shade lighter.
- And that brings our first session to an end. Oh, this is so exciting. I love making babies and I hope you’ve enjoyed it too.
- [MUSIC PLAYS]
Brief Summary
At a designer-baby clinic, a couple is pressured to choose a straight daughter with lighter skin to shield her from discrimination.
Key points
- A clinic visit takes a disturbing turn. A couple arrive excited to choose attributes for their designer baby. Their adviser turns each decision into a pitch shaped by prejudice and social danger.
- The adviser’s case for a “safer” daughter. When the couple choose a girl, the adviser lists the dangers women face and pushes them to reconsider. The conversation exposes how fear can be used to steer a deeply personal choice.
- Choosing a skin tone. The adviser lays out stark statistics about discrimination, then suggests the couple choose a lighter-skinned baby. Their shock gives way to pressure, persuasion, and an uneasy decision.
- The choice they can’t take back. After the adviser claims that a lighter shade could make their daughter’s life easier, the couple sit in silence before agreeing. The session ends with their decision made.
Episode highlights
- A clinic visit takes a disturbing turnA couple arrive excited to choose attributes for their designer baby. Their adviser turns each decision into a pitch shaped by prejudice and social danger.“We’re very excited!”1:00May 7, 2020
- The adviser’s case for a “safer” daughterWhen the couple choose a girl, the adviser lists the dangers women face and pushes them to reconsider. The conversation exposes how fear can be used to steer a deeply personal choice.“The right choice is the one that will keep your child safest.”1:56May 7, 2020
- Choosing a skin toneThe adviser lays out stark statistics about discrimination, then suggests the couple choose a lighter-skinned baby. Their shock gives way to pressure, persuasion, and an uneasy decision.“We’ll make her a shade lighter.”4:08May 7, 2020
- The choice they can’t take backAfter the adviser claims that a lighter shade could make their daughter’s life easier, the couple sit in silence before agreeing. The session ends with their decision made.“What’s your choice?”8:21May 7, 2020

